Against All Odds: Leading Nokia from Near Catastrophe to Global Success
By Jorma Ollila and Harri Saukkomaa
In his book ‘Against All Odds’, Nokia’s former CEO Jorma Ollila chronicles how a troubled conglomerate engaged in rubber, cable, forestry, electronics and power generation businesses became a global mobile phone behemoth, but lost out to the iPhone
D ShivakumarBy Jorma Ollila and Harri Saukkomaa
This book was written over the course of more than ten years.
No one was happy when I was chosen as Nokia’s CEO on January 16, 1992. Nokia’s share value dropped 10% that afternoon.
I knew that the previous generation had given me the responsibility of rebuilding a company they had destroyed.
I had to find good people who would believe in the company. I had to breathe new life into the company, so that people would believe in themselves.
For me working was as natural as breathing. Laziness was the start of a slippery slope.
The people I grew up with thought you could never do too much work. This was the mindset that helped Finland become a developed country.
Numbers revealed a much wider world. If I understood the numbers, then I would understand things well.
Knowledge has power, by which one could transform one’s destiny. With the help of knowledge, one could advance and do great things. With knowledge one could compete and never be limited.
Nokia was full of people who thought the same way as me. We couldn’t accept that anything was impossible.
I am at my best when I know I am well prepared, whether it is a speech, a deal or even a routine meeting.
Without a multicultural attitude, one cannot work in an international company.
Time after time, I returned from the Soviet Union with a feeling of relief—this economic system could never beat a market economy.
I felt uneasy about the atmosphere in Finland at the end of the 1970s. I was bothered by the intellectual dishonesty, the rigid resistance to change and the politicians’ ineffectuality.
According to a popular analysis, people can be divided into four groups: achievers, explorers, socialisers and killers.
Achievers are always aiming toward something bigger.
Achievers are curious about things, because new knowledge makes new achievements possible.
Achievers keep the promises they make to others, but also the ones they make to themselves.
All major decisions demand sacrifices.
A matrix structure is a practical way to run an international company.
Leaders do not lead boxes in an organisation, they lead people.
A good leader must always be ready to promote some surprising candidates in an organisation, without regard to official boxes.
I compelled my senior team to travel and meet customers and be externally focused.
I wasn’t an easy subordinate for anyone.
Depending on your world view, you may see life as a matter of chance or of destiny.
In the early 1980s, Nokia had become Finland’s most important electronics company. It made televisions, telephone exchange, mobile phones and computers.
But, in the 1980s, wellington boots were still Nokia’s best known product.
My first task at Nokia was to bring order to chaos.
Nokia’s complex governance model turned out to be a millstone around its neck in the 1980s. The company could not deal promptly or decisively with the many issues it was facing.
Senior executives were jostling for positions, more worried about themselves than doing the right thing for the company.
A sickness, a cancer had taken hold of Nokia and it was eating up the company. Head office spent its time in plots and power struggles.
Things are beautiful when all is well, but when luck runs out, it finds vengeance all the sweeter.
A good leader has to have three basic qualities: competence, will power and a desire to work hard.
People who are trying their best shouldn’t be punished for the odd mistake, but they must learn from every mistake.
I have never had time for conservative people. They see every change as threatening the heritage of the firm. Perhaps more to the point, they want their comfortable life to continue.
Product development has always been one of Nokia’s strengths. Engineers were always proud of their ability to develop new ideas and concepts.
In the 1990s, there were very few European companies where talented young people could rise to high responsibility. Nokia believed in giving young people more responsibility.
We introduced a six stage innovation process in Nokia. Everyone in the meeting looked at the same concept and same numbers. Everyone had one view of innovation.
Anssi Vanjoki, our head of mobile marketing, defined the Nokia brand along five dimensions: high technology, Nordic touch, individuality, freedom and lasting quality.
Nokia was the first to bring colour phones into a market that was dominated by black phones.
I got rid of the silo mentality in marketing, R&D, production and procurement.
Time is the most valuable resource of all and you can waste it on all the wrong things.
In 1992, we chose the slogan for Nokia: Connecting people. Everyone on the board liked it. We decided to wait for a month for us to be comfortable with it and then agreed on it.
My future for Nokia revolved around: Focus, global, mobile phones and high value added.
In 1992, we also articulated the values of the company: Customer orientation, achievement, continuous learning and respect for the individual.
As CEO I expected all senior people to have their facts and figures right.
No one knows the pressures of a CEO’s job until they do the job themselves.
It was good that no one in Nokia looked back and hankered for a broken glorious past.
Success often provides less information and learning. Failure brings huge amount of information and learning.
We agreed that Nokia would have low hierarchy, be flat and run on ‘teamwork’.
We identified three processes as key to Nokia: Strategic planning, financial control and HR management.
We encouraged people in meetings to say what was on their mind irrespective of level. Skirmishes were good in meetings to develop better trust.
In the early 1990s, Motorola sold phones to the army and police. Most people thought that limiting phones to a few professions was a good idea. Anssi Vanjoki felt that we must sell a phone to the common man and that’s how Nokia went mass and succeeded.
At the 1994 board meeting, we looked out and did a 2001 forecast—a business of $11 billion and a profit of $829 million. In reality we did a revenue of $31 billion and a profit of $5.9 billion. Nokia was the fastest growth company of those decades.
The leadership model at Nokia was unique. It was run by five people: me, Olli-Pekka Kallasvu, Sari Baldauf, Matti Alahuhta and Pekka Ala-Pietilä.
The company was run with little formal structure but much in the way of trust and information sharing.
We allowed contradictions to flourish, since this was better than artificial unanimity.
Anyone could challenge anybody in an argument over facts, but arguments about authority dominating an argument were never allowed.
We ran the company at four levels—the CEO, The Five, the executive committee and the top 200 managers.
The biggest company in its field is usually the least agile and doesn’t open up to new ideas. Motorola went through that in the 1990s.
The year 1994 was great. As a team, we had experience of tough times, but none of us had tasted great success. Reacting to success humbly is a big challenge for teams.
We mismanaged 1995—the supply chain, the components side, etc. We ended up giving a profit warning because of our inefficiencies and investors were furious with me and Nokia.
In 1996, Nokia launched the Communicator, a phone with an internet browser, fax, e-mail and a calendar. It was the work of one man, Reijo Paajanen, who worked on it against all opposition. This gave us tech leadership and this was the first smartphone.
A CEO’s relationship with the media is very important. It is better to say nothing than tell only part of the truth. Never comment on your competitors, guard against complacency and keep a clear head in a crisis.
In 1998, we overtook Motorola and became the No. 1 mobile company in the world. This was an objective we set in 1990 when we were a nobody.
In June 2001, Nokia gave the next profit warning because growth was a little below 10%.
Growth helps people move towards perfection. Growth in a company helps people all around.
A company is healthy when it grows, and the emotional bonus that growth provides for its workers is remarkable.
We never employed consultants without doing our homework first. We always had to have a sense of what we wanted to do before we invited anyone outside for a dialogue.
Companies usually make mistakes because they focus too much on the short term.
Employees can’t be motivated by structures, they cannot strike a balance between objectives. It is the job of senior management to see further and paint the picture.
Success is the gravest danger of all. It makes major companies arrogant and complacent.
Between 2004 and 2007, we tried to change direction and be far more software centric. We were in a sense a prisoner of our past success.
After the iPhone was launched, senior managers recognised that the Nokia operating system Symbian would not be able to compete with iOS. We sadly didn’t end up making quick moves to address this.
By January 2010, I was in discussions with the board to check if the current CEO, Olli-Pekka Kallasvuo, was the right person to lead Nokia into the future. (Ollila was CEO from 1992 to 2006 and chairman from 1999 to 2012.)
We hired executive search firm Spencer Stuart to get us a short list of potential CEOs.
Nokia saw huge success and then failed to make the right choices in software in the last few years. That led to its failure and subsequent sale to Microsoft.
By Jorma Ollila and Harri Saukkomaa
For over a decade, Founding Fuel has ignited bold leadership and groundbreaking insights. Keep the ideas flowing—fuel our mission with your commitment today.
Want to know more about our voluntary commitment model? Click here.
Was this article useful? Sign up for our daily newsletter below
About the author
Shivakumar is Operating Partner at Advent International. Before this, he was President (Corporate Strategy and Business Development) at Aditya Birla Group. Earlier assignments include: Chairman & CEO at Pepsico India and prior to that, Managing Director at Nokia India. Before joining Nokia, he worked with consumer electronics maker Philips and top consumer goods firm Hindustan Unilever. He is an engineer from IIT Chennai and an MBA from IIM Calcutta.
Shivakumar has written three books: Reflections - a collection of Shivs articles; The Right Choice - Resolving Ten Career Dilemmas; and The Art of Management. The latter two are business bestsellers.
Also by me
Trending