Conversations in a noisy place

Public discourse has descended into the shallows. Where is the space left for citizens to engage in deeper deliberations about their future?

Arun Maira

[Image by Gerd Altmann from Pixabay]

Dear friend,

Sixteen-year-old Greta Thunberg challenged world leaders at the United Nations: “People are suffering, people are dying, entire ecosystems are collapsing….and all you can talk about is money and fairytales of eternal economic growth. How dare you!” She challenged the dominant paradigm of economic growth driving policies everywhere, including in India. A more humane and ecologically sensitive paradigm is required. “How dare you turn to us (the children) for hope,” she said. You, the emperors, must change your clothes—the ideas with which you strut around—she implied.

“Are Western democracies becoming ungovernable?” asks The Economist. Elected governments are in office, but not in power, it says. Many countries in Europe cannot form stable governments because the largest party does not command a majority. Coalitions are unstable. Parliaments are unable to pass laws. “The home of failure to pass meaningful laws is the United States,” it says. Systems of electoral democracy have been exported by the West to the rest of the world, even by force—like in Iraq. Now the system is failing even in the West. People are becoming fed-up with politicians, who only want to be elected. Politicians in office don’t much care about finding solutions for long-term issues such as those that Thunberg highlighted. They are concerned about winning their next election.

Elected governments do not have incentives to think long, and to invest in policies whose outcomes will not come about during their period in office to boost their next election campaign. Media used to keep the public attention on citizens’ long-term concerns through short election cycles. Electronic media is now scrambling to hold viewers’ interests in very short news cycles to improve TRPs to sell more advertising. And social media, which has become ubiquitous, has reduced attention spans even further. Public discourse has descended into the shallows. Where is the space left for citizens to engage in deeper deliberations about their future?

An inspiring example of concerned citizens taking charge of the discourse is the Think Long Committee for California. It was formed by a non-partisan group of persons—labor leaders, community advocates, entrepreneurs, economists, and former government officials—none of whom were in an official position, but all were concerned about the future. Following a systematic plan for their year-long deliberations, they found an institutional solution for California’s governance which is now being adopted by the government.

India’s elected politicians, like their counterparts everywhere, are caught in their short-term interests. India’s media—print, electronic, and social—has become very shallow too. Who will step up to convene democratic, non-partisan deliberations amongst Indian citizens? How can technology be used to facilitate them and increase citizens’ participation without losing the richness of face-to-face dialogues?

I am grateful to Founding Fuel for curating a conversation about how we will deliberate thoughtfully about shaping our collective future.  

Personally, I find that there is nothing like a good book to make me think deeply. Books demand sustained and deep attention, much more than videos do, and much more than the tweets of presidents and celebrities of course! Technology is helping my reading. Kindle enables me to carry many books around with me, to read in the spaces in my time that I make for them.   

Happy reading.

Arun Maira

With Team Founding Fuel

Featured Stories

Economies of scope: Singapore’s alternative approach to progress

In the relatively short time since it became independent in 1965, Singapore has made giant strides. The country illustrates well the power of local systems solutions, purpose-driven networks, and inducing all parts of the government and all stakeholders to work together. (By Arun Maira. Read Time: 8 mins)

This essay is part of the Masterclass on TransformingSystems with Arun Maira: A special learning project, where Maira led a public conversation with thought leaders on three themes: A new model of change, Designing purpose driven networks, and Building ethical leaders.

The promise and perils of breakthroughs

November 09, 2019: A roundup of news and perspective on disruptive technology. In this issue: Drones, quantum computing, and gene editing. (By NS Ramnath. Read Time: 3 mins)

Arun Maira Recommends

When the People Speak: Deliberative Democracy and Public Consultation, by James S. Fishkin

Fishkin gives an analysis of the evolution of democratic institutions from Athens, through the debates among the Founding Fathers of the US Constitution, and into the 20th century, explaining the dilemmas in obtaining both ‘reach’ in the numbers who participate and the ‘richness’ of the dialogues. He provides architectural principles for the design of good processes, using technology also. 

The Econocracy: On the Perils of Leaving Economics to the Experts, by Joe Earle, Cahal Moran, and Zach Ward-Moran

Economics has become the over-arching discipline, and the reigning ideology of our time, for organising human affairs. This book, written by a collective of dissident graduate students, exposes many flimsy theoretical foundations on which neo-classical economics stands.

Future Politics: Living Together in a World Transformed by Tech, by Jamie Susskind

To what extent should our lives be directed and controlled by powerful digital systems and on what terms? Software code is the new law. It is not written in parliaments, but by technologists out of public sight. Moreover, these new-age law-makers are serving private interests, not governments. How will politics change, and how should governance of technology be changed?

The Value of Everything: Making and Taking in the Global Economy, by Mariana Mazzucato

Creating wealth from wealth has become the fastest growing industry, producing enormous wealth for those in it. Mazzucato explains the historically intertwined evolution of ideas in economics and government policies, and the influence of wealth in shaping these ideas. The result is that, whereas the Gini coefficient for inequality of labour incomes, at 40 to 50 in many countries is distressing, the Gini coefficient for income from property has reached 90 in many countries—almost as high as it can theoretically get!

Renovating Democracies (Great Transformations), by Nathan Gardels and Nicholas Berggruen

There is increasing dissatisfaction in Western democracies with the performance of their governments. On the other side of the world, China and Singapore have provided another model of governance that is improving the welfare of citizens with sustained investments in social and physical infrastructure. The authors explain the weaknesses and strengths of both systems. They describe a real experiment underway in California (which they are a part of) to combine the strengths within both systems to reconstruct the governance of the state of California, which is urgently in need of reform—witness the decline in its vaunted public education system and the alarming erosion of its environmental capital.

From Our Archives

The new China is more than just about growth

[Alibaba founder Jack Ma and Tesla’s Elon Musk at the 2019 World AI Conference held in Shanghai. Photo from WAIC]

Today, the country’s focus is on exploiting the benefits of economic modernisation to redefine the goals of society in three critical areas: environmental regulation, technological innovation, and corporate social responsibility. Insights from a week-long immersion. (By G Venkat Raman)

Was this article useful? Sign up for our daily newsletter below


Login to comment

About the author

Arun Maira
Arun Maira

Former Chairman, BCG India &

Member, Planning Commission

Former Member, Planning Commission of India
Former Chairman, Boston Consulting Group, India
Chairman, HelpAge International

Any discussion on policy, the future of India, and indeed the world, is enriched with Arun Maira’s views, and not just because he was a member of the Planning Commission of India for five years till June 2014. Arun is one of those rare people who have held leadership positions in both, the private as well as the public sector, bringing a unique perspective on how civil society, the government, and the private sector can work more closely to improve the world for everyone. He has led three rounds of participative and comprehensive scenario building for the future of India: in 1999 (with the Confederation of Indian Industry), 2005 (with the World Economic Forum), and 2011 (with the Planning Commission).

In his career spanning five decades, Arun has led several organisations, including the Boston Consulting Group in India, where he was chairman for eight years till 2008. He was also the chairman of Axis Bank Foundation and Save the Children, India. He was a board member of the India Brand Equity Foundation, the Indian Institute of Corporate Affairs, and the UN Global Compact, and WWF India.

In the early part of his career, he spent 25 years in the Tata group at various important positions. He was also a member of the Board of Tata Motors (then called TELCO). After leaving the Tatas, Arun joined Arthur D Little Inc (ADL), the international management consultancy, in the US, where he advised companies across sectors and geographies on their growth strategies and handling transformational change.

Recognising his astute understanding of both macro as well as micro policy issues, Arun has been involved in several government committees and organisations, including the National Innovation Council. He has been on the board of several companies as well as educational institutions and has chaired several national committees of the Confederation of Indian Industries.

In 2009, Arun was appointed as a member of the Planning Commission (now replaced by the NITI Aayog), which is led by the Prime Minister of India. At this minister-level position, he led the development of strategies for the country on issues relating to industrialisation and urbanisation. He also advised the Commission on its future role.

With his vast experience and expertise, Arun is indeed a thought leader. He is invited to speak at various forums and has written several books that capture his insights.

His most recent book, A Billion Fireflies: Critical Conversations to Shape a New Post-Pandemic World and Transforming Systems: Why the World Needs a New Ethical Toolkit before that, talk about how systemic problems of social inequality and environmental unsustainability are becoming intolerable. Prevalent precepts of good business management and best practices in government as well as civil society organisations are failing the needs of humanity. This calls for a whole new toolkit founded on systems thinking, ethical reasoning and deep listening. And that civil society, government and private companies need to work together to encourage a variety of local systems solutions for deep-rooted issues that impact different communities differently.

His previous books include An Upstart in Government: Journeys of Change and Learning (2016); Redesigning the Aeroplane While Flying: Reforming Institutions (2014)Remaking India: One Country, One DestinyTransforming Capitalism: Improving the World for EveryoneShaping the Future: Aspirational Leadership in India and Beyond; and Listening for Well-Being: Conversations with People Not Like Us (2017).

Also by me

You might also like